Verified market statistics currently unavailable for Mahtomedi. Contact us for the latest comparables.
The area
Mahtomedi wraps the east side of White Bear Lake with mature neighborhoods, a beloved school district, and a small-town feel just 20 minutes from downtown St. Paul.
What you can expect in Mahtomedi
- Mid-century ramblers, two-stories, and lakefront estates.
- Median list price around $560K, with median days on market around 18.
- 20 min to downtown St. Paul, 30 min to Minneapolis.
- Lifestyle: Wildwood Park and the Bruce Vento Trail; Manitou Days and lakeside summers; Downtown White Bear Lake shops and dining nearby.
- Mahtomedi Public Schools — consistently ranked among Minnesota's best.
- Overall feel: Lakeside community with a top-tier school district.
What buyers often compare here
- Larger single-family homes and executive housing
- Shorter commutes into downtown Minneapolis or St. Paul
- Walkable retail, cafes, and neighborhood parks
- Lake and river access, boating, and waterfront proximity
Why people live here
- ●Mahtomedi Public Schools (ISD 832) — well-regarded
- ●White Bear Lake recreation and boating
- ●Quiet, family-oriented community
- ●Easy access to I-694 and Hwy 36
Lifestyle
- Wildwood Park and the Bruce Vento Trail
- Manitou Days and lakeside summers
- Downtown White Bear Lake shops and dining nearby
Housing stock
Mid-century ramblers, two-stories, and lakefront estates.
Schools
Mahtomedi Public Schools — consistently ranked among Minnesota's best.
School district boundaries and program information change. Buyers should verify current attendance areas and school details directly with the district.
Commute
20 min to downtown St. Paul, 30 min to Minneapolis.
Buyers
Buying in Mahtomedi?
We'll help you compare neighborhoods, property condition, pricing, commute, resale, and offer strategy before you write.
Our team helps buyers evaluate the housing, location, and transaction considerations that matter in Mahtomedi. We compare comparable homes and pockets within Mahtomedi, flag deferred maintenance before you fall in love, and help structure an offer that fits current market dynamics. Recent median days on market in Mahtomedi has been around 18, which shapes how competitive an offer needs to be.
Get My Mahtomedi Home SearchSellers
Selling in Mahtomedi?
We'll help you understand your value, what to prep, what to skip, and how to position your home against current competition.
Pricing in Mahtomedi is nuanced — a few blocks can change value. We build a list price from recent sold comps, active competition, and current inventory, then walk your home and give you an honest list of prep that actually moves the needle in this market — and what to skip. Median list price has moved +4.4% year over year here — one input among comps, condition, and current active competition.
Get a Mahtomedi Seller PlanAsk us about Mahtomedi.
Thinking about buying or selling in Mahtomedi? We're happy to give you the honest local perspective — what buyers love, what to watch for, and how the market is moving right now.